16 Nickels Arcade

In Praise of Nickels Arcade — and in Indictment of What Followed

Loading
loading...

16 Nickels Arcade

November 21, 2026
mike@standardsmichigan.com
,

WASHTENAW COUNTY WEATHER

https://standardsmichigan.com/136343-2/

Ann Arbor has spent more than a century demonstrating that  architectural progress and architectural

improvement are not necessarily the same thing.

Consider Nickels Arcade, opened in 1918. Its glass-vaulted roof, ornamental detailing, tiled floors and intimate storefronts constitute an architectural argument that requires no explanation.  It is a place made for people, not merely for the efficient extraction of rent from a parcel of land.

Its builders understood something that seems to have escaped generations of their successors:
a building has obligations to the street, to its neighbors and to people who have not yet been born.

Then came the increasingly familiar vocabulary of architectural surrender: curtain walls, anonymous façades, oversized building masses, disposable finishes and ground floors that offer pedestrians little more than a view of the elevator lobby.

Every generation of developers seems determined to prove that the previous generation failed to maximize the allowable floor-area ratio.

The result is a city in which a century-old shopping arcade can feel more contemporary, more humane and more commercially inviting than buildings completed last Tuesday.

Of course, Ann Arbor needs housing, offices, laboratories and new construction. Cities cannot be preserved in amber. But growth is not an architectural philosophy, density is not a substitute for beauty and compliance with the building code is not evidence of civic achievement.

An architect’s responsibility does not end at the property line. Nor should a developer’s imagination end at the pro forma.

Nickels Arcade reminds us that private investment can produce a public inheritance. Its architecture enriches the experience of people who never spend a dollar inside it.  That is the difference between building something in a city and building something for a city.

A century from now, will pedestrians admire today’s additions to Ann Arbor with the same affection? Or will they hurry past them on their way to Nickels Arcade?

International Zoning Code

Michigan Central: Summer-Fall

Layout mode
Predefined Skins
Custom Colors
Choose your skin color
Patterns Background
Images Background
Standards Michigan
error: Content is protected !!
Skip to content